The Index — Reviews
Places we’ve stood behind.
- Scored 7.5 out of 10
West Village · Cocktail bar
Katana Kitten
$$$ · Reviewed July 2026
Masa Urushido's Japanese-American cocktail bar has been the best argument for drinking on Hudson Street since 2018. The Hinoki Martini alone is worth the trip. Come early, claim two stools at the bamboo bar, and let the night sort itself out.
- Scored 9 out of 10
West Village · Cocktail bar
Little Branch
$ · Reviewed July 2026
Unmarked door on 7th Avenue, steep stairs down, mustard walls, corrugated steel ceiling, live jazz trio at 10. Little Branch is nearly twenty years old and still the most reliably great cocktail bar in the West Village. Order a classic. Stay too long.
- Scored 7.5 out of 10
West Village · Restaurant
Dante West Village
$$$ · Reviewed July 2026
Candlelit booths, velvet banquettes, fifty-plus cocktails, and a Negroni that comes out of a tap. The West Village location of a legendary name — less tourist magnet than the original, more date-night room. Show up before 5 for $10 martinis.
- Scored 8.5 out of 10
West Village · Book store
Three Lives & Company
Reviewed June 2026
Open since 1978, still tracked by index card. The red double doors on the corner of 10th and Waverly open onto 675 square feet of dark wood, creaking floors, and classical music — the best fifteen minutes you can spend before dinner in the West Village.
- Scored 5.5 out of 10
West Village · Italian restaurant
Canto West Village
$$$ · Reviewed June 2026
A candlelit room on Perry Street with brick walls, butcher-block tables, and a frozen espresso martini that's been all over Instagram. Pretty enough to earn a second date. Whether the pasta delivers is a different question.
- Scored 7.5 out of 10
West Village · Chocolate shop
Venchi Chocolate Bleecker St
Reviewed June 2026
A Turinese chocolate house that opened in the old Grom space on Bleecker — gelato in waffle cones, crêpes from a chocolate fountain, and a gold-accented room small enough that you'll be standing close. Open until midnight on weekends.
- Scored 6.5 out of 10
West Village · Ice cream shop
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
$$ · Reviewed June 2026
Started as a yellow food truck in 2008, now the best scoop stop in the West Village. Earl Grey and Honeycomb in a cone. Benches outside on a tree-lined block. The kind of detour that turns into a twenty-minute linger.
- Scored 6.5 out of 10
West Village · Bakery
Aux Merveilleux de Fred
$ · Reviewed June 2026
A Lille-born meringue shop in a landmarked 1850 West Village townhouse — no seats, no menu to study, just a glass case of frosted cream-and-meringue spheres in six flavors and a croissant that Robert Sietsema ranks among the city's best. Takes four minutes. Worth the detour.
- Scored 8 out of 10
West Village · Northern Italian restaurant
Osteria Carlina West Village
$$$ · Reviewed June 2026
A Turin-born husband-and-wife operation opened in 2021, and the West Village has been quietly returning ever since. Exposed brick, low light, tableside truffle shaving on the angel hair. No cocktails — wine, beer, and vermouth only. Book it or regret it.
- Scored 7 out of 10
West Village · Wine bar
LELABAR
$$ · Reviewed June 2026
LELABAR is a useful West Village wine bar, which is not the same thing as a great one. Low light, solid wine, easy bar seating, and enough small plates to keep the night moving. It works best when you are already nearby.
- Scored 8 out of 10
West Village · Wine bar
WEST10WEST
$$$ · Reviewed May 2026
Small plates, natural wine, and West Village lighting doing exactly what West Village lighting is supposed to do.