Skip to content

A date plan

Wine, Bites & Gelato on the Upper West Side

Date · Upper West Side · Fun & Playful · $

A romantic evening of Italian wine, Mediterranean small plates, and creamy gelato in the heart of the Upper West Side.

01Drinks & Dinner

Upper West Side · $$ · Wine bar · Bar

This cozy Italian wine bar is the real deal—think low lighting, a thoughtful wine list, and small plates that pair beautifully with whatever you're sipping. The Mediterranean vibe is intimate without trying too hard, and the staff knows their stuff. Perfect for a date that feels effortlessly romantic.

1012 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025

~1.3 mi — consider a cab or the subway. As you leave Elis, head south on Amsterdam Ave—you'll pass classic brownstones and tree-lined blocks that are quintessentially Upper West Side. Gelateria Gentile is a natural next stop, keeping you on the same avenue and in that intimate, neighborhood feel.

02Dessert

Upper West Side · $ · Ice cream shop

Just a short stroll down Amsterdam, this is where you go for creamy, authentic Italian gelato made the right way. The flavors rotate seasonally and they don't skimp on quality—one scoop each and you've got the perfect sweet note to end the night.

498 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024

Curated by NYC Date Ideas