Skip to content

A date plan

Craft Cocktails, Pasta, and a Nightcap in Prospect Heights

Date · Prospect Heights · Romantic · $$$

A romantic Prospect Heights evening that moves from one of Brooklyn's best no-sign cocktail bars to a 44-seat wood-fired gem, then winds down with oysters and intimate late-night drinks.

01Drinks & Appetizers

Prospect Heights · $$ · Cocktail bar

There's no sign on the door at Weather Up — just a velvet curtain separating you from Vanderbilt Ave and, inside, white subway tile, a copper bar, and amber light that makes everyone look good. Pull up two stools and let the bartender riff; they'll go off-menu if you describe what you're in the mood for. This is the kind of place where the second drink arrives before you notice the first one is gone.

589 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238

~1 min walk (0.0 mi). From Weather Up, it's a short stroll south on Vanderbilt to Wayward Fare — peek into the boutiques and brownstone stoops along the way. The neighborhood gets quieter and prettier the further down you go.

02Dinner

Prospect Heights · $$ · Italian restaurant · Mediterranean restaurant

Wayward Fare is 44 seats inside a former pizzeria — exposed brick, wood-fired oven still crackling — but the menu roams from Spain to Turkey to Greece with total confidence. Start with the oven-roasted oysters with Parm and cherry peppers, then commit to the lamb merguez manti with labneh; it's the kind of dish that derails the conversation in the best way. The Med-focused wine list is in good hands, and the Spiced Sour (vodka, apricot, turmeric, cardamom) is a worthy opening move if you're still in cocktail mode.

554 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238

~5 min walk (0.2 mi). Heading to Bar Francis, you'll cross over toward Fulton St — note that this nudges you slightly toward the Fort Greene/Clinton Hill border, but it's close enough to Prospect Heights that it feels like the same evening. Keep an eye out for the old neo-Gothic details on the buildings along the way.

03Dessert & Nightcap

Prospect Heights · $$ · Cocktail bar · Bar

Bar Francis on Fulton is a cozy, candlelit pocket of a bar — the kind of place that feels like a secret even when it's full. Order the oysters if you're still grazing, and let the cocktail list do the deciding for dessert. It's intimate in the way that actually means something: small room, low light, nowhere else you need to be.

810 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11238

Curated by NYC Date Ideas